Review: Modcloth On a Barrel Roll Skirt

Modcloth On a Barrel Roll Skirt_
Skirt: Modcloth – size XS (before alterations)

When Jess showed me this dress , I instantly fell in love with the print.  I was browsing and was thrilled when I noticed it came in a skirt version.  I sat on it for awhile before ordering making sure that it would be something I would wear more than once. I’m trying to think through my purchases more instead of just buying on impulse. This is a constant work in progress but I’m getting there. After several weeks of contemplating, I decided to order it.  I don’t have too much experience with Modcloth but the items I have bought have always ran big. I did not expect this to fit. 
Modcloth On a Barrel Roll Skirt_-4
Measurements of XS: Waist laying flat = 11.5″, total length = 23″ (hemmed to exactly 20″) **Online says the XS is 22.5″**
Fit: I decided to order the XS based on the reviews and the waist fits me perfectly!  Unfortunately the length is too long on me (I’m 5′ tall) and had to take it up 3″.  I prefer my full/flared skirts to hit right at my knees.  I don’t think this style works when the skirt is too short.  
Quality: Amazing. It’s so well made and fully lined. It’s much heavier than I expected.  The only complaint I have is that I noticed that the skirt had several sections  that they pieced together instead of 1 or 2 panels. I thought that was a bit strange but you can’t tell unless you look really closely. Online states that it’s semi-sheer but I didnt’ find this to be the case.  It has a side zipper and button closure and a cute front pocket. I wish it had side pockets instead of one big pocket but I guess that’s what makes it unique. 
Modcloth On a Barrel Roll Skirt_-5
Material:  It’s made out of 100% cotton and is hand wash only. This might be a deal breaker for some but I plan to wash in a garment bag on delicate cycle. 
Price: $57.99 – which I don’t think is a bad price because of the quality. I think it’s worth every penny. 
Verdict: Highly recommend and keeping! 
Modcloth On a Barrel Roll Skirt_-3
Top: Banana Republic – size 00P (similar here)
Belt: Ferragamo (buy here)
Shoes: Christian Louboutin simple 85 (buy here)
Necklace: Pearls (similar here)
Purse: Prada Gardener Tote
The print is drawings of prop planes, fighter jets and helicopters – so adorable.  It’s got such a retro/vintage vibe to it and I can’t get enough! I love that it’s a cream color which makes it easy to pair tops with.  I’ve already worn it to work and it was a big hit.  I’ve been loving flared/a-line skirts lately that I decided to pick up this skirt and hope I like it as much.  I’ve been looking for a skirt to replace my Forever 21 pleated polkadot skirt which is too short for me and decided to get this See you round skirt.  I had to order filler to get free shipping so I added this Decades Dance skirt to try. 
What I love about Modcloth is the free return shipping! This alleviates the stress if something doesn’t work out. You get free shipping on all orders above $50.
Modcloth On a Barrel Roll Skirt_-6
This is such a fun skirt and I’m really happy I got it. I see that it’s sold out online but if there is enough demand, they will bring it back.  All you have to do is sign in and click “I NEED IT” button, select your size and they will email you when it comes back in stock.  I know several ladies have already emailed me asking about this after I posted it here and here.  Hopefully they will bring it back soon 🙂  
What are your thoughts on this skirt? 
Previous Post

Review: J.Crew Striped City Mini in Ripstop Cotton

Next Post

Review: Ann Taylor + J.Crew + Banana Republic Petite Spring Dresses

Leave a comment!

  1. I love this skirt. I think it’s so cute and fun! The length definitely fits better after the hem. I like how you accessorized it with the Ferragamo Belt and Prada Tote, so classy. When I first saw the See You Round Skirt, I actually thought of you. It looked like something you would definitely enjoy, the polka dots and the full skirt. I can’t wait to see how you style that one! 🙂

  2. I absolutely LOVE the skirt on you! So glad you got it. I’m reading a bunch of the reviews and it runs smaller so it totally had you name all over it. hehe I really hope a small or maybe even a medium comes back in stock if it turns small. I can’t wait to see the other skirts you ordered. I saw the blue polka dot skirt too but I prefer your white with blue dot J.Crew skirt. If only J.Crew factory would restock their version!